Cheryl’s Global Soul
Chicken and pancakes, jerk wings and global comfort food on Underhill Avenue.
01 / The experience
Cheryl Smith’s comfort food crosses borders.
Chicken and pancakes, jerk wings and global comfort food on Underhill Avenue.
≈ $40 per personGlobal comfort foodPancakes and fried chicken explain much of the appeal of Cheryl’s Global Soul. The combination brings a crisp, savoury main onto the same plate as a breakfast favourite, with honey mustard and herb crème fraîche giving it its own character. It is one way into a menu that moves between American brunch, Caribbean seasoning and dishes drawn from further afield. The connections come through comfort and generous meals rather than a single national cuisine.
Chef Cheryl Smith opened the restaurant in 2006. Her Jamaican family background is one thread in its story, alongside a career in professional kitchens and catering. The room is personal too: timber across the frontage and ceiling, white-painted brick, strings of coloured lights and an elephant painting above the tables. It is a small neighbourhood restaurant with a recognisable setting, close enough to Brooklyn’s museum and garden district to become part of a larger outing.
Brunch has several distinct routes. Buttermilk pancakes come with berries or banana and Chantilly cream; brioche French toast takes caramelised apples and cream instead. An omelette with Brie, scallions and tomato offers a savoury alternative without the fried chicken. The menu’s range makes a mixed breakfast table possible, but the weekend brunch works on arrival rather than reserved seating.
Later dishes give the kitchen more room. Jerk chicken wings bring Caribbean seasoning into a smaller plate. Sake-glazed salmon comes with rice, spinach and nori, while the catfish can be blackened or fried and served with macaroni and cheese and spinach. The tonkatsu bowl takes another direction, combining panko-coated pork with jasmine rice, pickled vegetables and a sweet-and-sour sauce. These dishes are different meals, not variations on a standard brunch plate.
There is also a substantial vegetable choice. The Moroccan-spiced tagine brings eggplant, kabocha squash, chickpeas, tofu and fennel over couscous. A separate salad combines arugula, dried cranberries and Stilton, giving the leaves a sweet and salty contrast. Those ingredients matter when choosing between a lighter plate and a full meal; the couscous and cheese also make clear that vegetarian dishes do not all answer the same dietary requirements.
Underhill Avenue places Cheryl’s within Prospect Heights, west of Brooklyn Museum and Brooklyn Botanic Garden. It is a seated alternative to a quick café lunch, and the evening menu gives it a role after the galleries as well as before them. Dinner enquiries go directly to the restaurant, while weekend brunch remains first come, first served.

In pictures
The full gallery.
04 / Before you go
Plan your visit
Food & drink
≈ $40 per person
≈ $40 per person allows for a main, one non-alcoholic drink, tax and a service allowance. Fish mains or extra courses increase the total.
Menu examples before tax: buttermilk pancakes $18; pancakes with crispy fried chicken $21; vegetable tagine $21; sake-glazed salmon $31.
Opening
Tuesday–Friday 11:00–21:00; Saturday–Sunday 10:00–21:00. Contact the restaurant for Monday hours.
Weekend brunch 10:00–16:00; dinner 17:00–21:00.
Monday hours and the weekday switch between daytime and dinner menus are not confirmed; contact the restaurant for those services.
Arrival
236 Underhill Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11238
Use the timber-fronted entrance at 236 Underhill Avenue, between St Johns Place and Lincoln Place. The Cheryl’s sign sits above the restaurant frontage.
Ordering & tables
Weekend brunch is first come, first served. Dinner reservations are welcome; call 347 529 2855 to enquire. The telephone action is a contact route, not a confirmed reservation.
Accessibility
Call 347 529 2855 about entrance, seating and toilet access. The menu includes vegetarian dishes; couscous contains wheat, tofu contains soy and Stilton contains milk. Discuss allergies with the restaurant.
Location & nearby places
Continue exploring / New York
More to explore
in New York
Find another place for your itinerary, or explore all things to do in New York.
06 / Good to know
Cheryl’s Global Soul: frequently asked questions
01Can I reserve weekend brunch?
Weekend brunch is first come, first served. The restaurant welcomes dinner reservation enquiries by telephone.
02What is the substantial vegetarian option?
The vegetable tagine combines eggplant, kabocha squash, chickpeas, tofu and fennel over couscous. Discuss vegan preparation and allergies directly with the kitchen.
03Does it open on Mondays?
Monday hours are not confirmed. Call the restaurant before arranging a Monday visit.




