Skip to content
View nextSylvia’s

Lucali Brooklyn

A candlelit Carroll Gardens pizza evening for visitors happy to make the waitlist part of a Brooklyn food outing.

Plan this experience
Explore the story
CostEstimated $38.66 per person with the standard drink choice, tax and the stated service/tip allowance.
Time to allowAllow about 150 minutes, plus any queue.
PlaceCarroll Gardens, Brooklyn

01 / The experience

A Brooklyn evening built around pizza.

A candlelit Carroll Gardens pizza evening for visitors happy to make the waitlist part of a Brooklyn food outing.

$$Estimated $38.66 per person with the standard drink choice, tax and the stated service/tip allowance.Whole-pie pizza restaurant

Lucali is a reason to give Carroll Gardens an evening of its own. The Brooklyn restaurant keeps the food proposition unusually focused: a large pizza with basil, optional toppings and calzones. That short list makes the visit about a particular pizza dinner rather than a broad Italian restaurant menu.

The plain pie is a useful starting point for a first visit. Add toppings because you want them, with pepperoni, garlic and vegetables among the published choices. A calzone gives a different way to share the meal, and the menu lists it in two sizes. Choose the combination around the group’s appetite rather than order one of everything simply because the list is short.

The evening’s logistics are part of the decision to come. Lucali uses a first-come waitlist rather than reservations, accepts cash and offers BYOB. These conditions make it appealing for a flexible Brooklyn outing and difficult to combine with a fixed performance or uncertain finish elsewhere.

Choose Lucali if a destination pizza meal is worth the separate journey and possible wait to you. It is a different commitment from a Manhattan slice stop: the restaurant, the neighbourhood and the evening together form the outing. Keep another practical dinner option available if the wait would consume the time you wanted for the visit.

Lucali Brooklyn, New York
Restaurants & countersLucali BrooklynNew York

04 / Before you go

Plan your visit

Allow about 150 minutes, plus any queue.

Food & drink

Estimated $38.66 per person with the standard drink choice, tax and the stated service/tip allowance.

Food allowance
$25.00
Standard drinks
$5.00
Sales tax allowance
$2.66
Service / administrative fee
$0.00
Tip allowance
$6.00

Editable per-person estimate; includes the selected drink, sales tax and the stated service or tip allowance. Extra courses, supplements and booking fees are separate.

Change drinks and tip in your itinerary or enter the actual party total. Optional alcohol is for guests aged 21 or over; no alcohol is selected automatically.

Other drinks, supplements and booking charges can change the total.

View menu & booking

When to visit

17:00–23:00; closed Tuesday. The waitlist starts at 16:00.

Arrive

Carroll St · F/G. Walk west towards Henry Street and south to 575 Henry Street.

575 Henry Street, New York, NY

Small room and potential pavement wait; ask directly about the entrance, table and toilet route.

Journey times are daytime estimates, including the street approach. Add queues, screening and internal venue walks separately. Choose stations and operating lifts to suit your access needs.

Get directions

Plan your visit

No reservations; add your name in person from 16:00 and bring cash. BYOB has its own corkage charge. A spot on the list is not a promised dining time.

Share the current $32 large pie and add toppings or a calzone by appetite; the per-person allowance assumes sharing.

Cheese and wheat are fundamental; ask about toppings and any dietary limitations.

Menu & visit details

Location & nearby places

Explore around Lucali Brooklyn

The map will load when you reach it.

Continue exploring / New York

Find another place for your itinerary, or explore all things to do in New York.

06 / Good to know

Lucali Brooklyn: frequently asked questions

01What should I order?

Share the current $32 large pie and add toppings or a calzone by appetite; the per-person allowance assumes sharing.

02When can I visit?

17:00–23:00; closed Tuesday. The waitlist starts at 16:00.

03How should I book or join the queue?

No reservations; add your name in person from 16:00 and bring cash. BYOB has its own corkage charge. A spot on the list is not a promised dining time.

04What should I allow for food and drinks?

Estimated $38.66 per person with the standard drink choice, tax and the stated service/tip allowance.

05What are the dietary and access considerations?

Cheese and wheat are fundamental; ask about toppings and any dietary limitations. Small room and potential pavement wait; ask directly about the entrance, table and toilet route.