Skip to content
View nextGargiulo’s

Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitana

Coal-oven pizza from a 1924 family pizzeria, now weekend takeaway only.

Plan this experience
Explore the story
Cost≈ $25 per person
Time to allowAllow about 40 minutes.
PlaceConey Island, Brooklyn

01 / The experience

A coal-oven pizza with a long family history.

Coal-oven pizza from a 1924 family pizzeria, now weekend takeaway only.

$$Allow around $25 per person for a shared whole pie and drink; the number of people sharing changes the total.Coal-oven pizza

Totonno’s works with a small set of ingredients and a very particular oven. Tomato, mozzarella, grated cheese and oil cover the Traditional pizza; the White pizza leaves out the tomato. The thin, charred edge and the patches of fresh mozzarella give the pies their identity. There is little decoration between the baking and the box.

Anthony “Totonno” Pero opened the Neptune Avenue pizzeria in 1924 after working at Lombardi’s in Manhattan. The family business became one of New York’s enduring coal-oven pizza addresses. Photographs, clippings and memorabilia still cover the room, connecting the present collection counter to generations of customers and pizza makers. The old red booths and checkered floor remain part of that setting.

A weekend visit now means takeaway. The room is not operating as a sit-down restaurant, and the short Saturday-and-Sunday opening window makes the food the purpose of the journey. Orders are for whole pies. A Traditional pizza is the direct introduction to the tomato-and-mozzarella combination; the White offers a different balance of cheese and crust without a tomato base.

The preparation matters as much as the small menu. A long peel carries the pizza through the coal oven, and the finished pie is handled as a whole before collection. The crust’s darker patches are part of that baking style. The shop’s own motto, “as long as there’s dough”, also explains why availability can end before a visitor’s ideal collection time.

Neptune Avenue sits inland from the boardwalk. Totonno’s therefore adds a neighbourhood destination to the seaside outing rather than another concession along the promenade. Its history, limited menu and weekend-only collection give it a distinct place beside Coney Island’s hot dogs, sweets and seafood.

Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitana, New York
Restaurants & countersTotonno’s Pizzeria NapolitanaNew York

04 / Before you go

Plan your visit

Allow about 40 minutes.

Food & drink

≈ $25 per person

Allow around $25 per person for a shared whole pie and drink; the number of people sharing changes the total.

The order, drinks and service change the total.

Menu & venue information

Opening

Saturday–Sunday 12:00–17:30; Monday–Friday closed.

Arrival

1524 Neptune Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11224

Find the gold-lettered Totonno’s shop on Neptune Avenue between West 15th and West 16th streets, inland from the boardwalk.

Get directions

Ordering & tables

Takeaway and delivery only; no indoor dining. Whole pies are ordered through the official site’s linked services or by telephone.

Availability can end when the dough sells out. Pizza contains wheat and dairy.

Call Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitana

Location & nearby places

Explore around Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitana

The map will load when you reach it.

Continue exploring / New York

Find another place for your itinerary, or explore all things to do in New York.

06 / Good to know

Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitana: frequently asked questions

01How do I plan this visit?

Takeaway and delivery only; no indoor dining. Whole pies are ordered through the official site’s linked services or by telephone.

02What affects access or participation?

Contact the venue about step-free entry, seating and toilet access before an access-dependent visit. Availability can end when the dough sells out. Pizza contains wheat and dairy.