Skip to content
View nextPierozek

Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop

Classic cake and raised doughnuts, breakfast sandwiches and a retro Greenpoint counter.

Plan this experience
Explore the story
Cost≈ $10 per person
Time to allow30 minutes
PlaceGreenpoint · Manhattan Avenue, Brooklyn

01 / The experience

A Greenpoint doughnut counter with more than one kind of classic.

Classic cake and raised doughnuts, breakfast sandwiches and a retro Greenpoint counter.

$≈ $10 per personDoughnuts & breakfast

Peter Pan’s green frontage and striped awning lead to a pastry counter that still has a neighbourhood rhythm. Trays of doughnuts sit behind glass and on white shelves; staff work in the shop’s familiar pink-and-mint uniforms. The family-owned bakery has served Greenpoint for more than six decades, and the appeal remains a recognisable breakfast rather than a complicated restaurant occasion.

The menu makes a useful distinction between raised and cake doughnuts. Honey Dip, sugar twists, coconut and fruit-filled varieties belong to the yeast-dough side, with a lighter structure beneath the glaze or coating. Old Fashioned, chocolate cake, blueberry buttermilk and sour-cream versions offer a more substantial crumb. Buying one of each gives a clearer sense of the shop than choosing several variations of the same glazed ring.

Filled and decorated specials take the selection further. Boston Cream puts custard beneath a chocolate top; cream-crumb versions combine a raised doughnut with cream and a crumb topping. The official menu’s red-velvet range includes both cake and cream-crumb treatments, so the name alone does not describe a single doughnut. Eclairs, bowties and French crullers add other shapes to the case.

There is a proper breakfast menu behind the sweet display. Bagels, rolls, flagels and bialys can form the base of a sandwich with eggs, cheese and a choice of bacon, sausage, ham or lox. A simple buttered bagel and coffee is therefore as natural an order as a box of doughnuts. Cookies, crumb cake, cinnamon buns and muffins also keep the pastry selection broader than its best-known item.

Seasonal baking follows a different calendar from the everyday counter. Autumn brings apple-cider and pumpkin varieties; winter adds holiday pastries and flavours. Those changing trays sit within the same small shop on Manhattan Avenue. A stop here belongs comfortably alongside Greenpoint’s Polish shops and cafés, with Pierozek farther south offering the sit-down meal and Peter Pan supplying the classic bakery counter.

Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop, New York
Coffee, bagels & bakingPeter Pan Donut & Pastry ShopNew York

04 / Before you go

Plan your visit

Food & drink

≈ $10 per person

The allowance is for a small doughnut-and-coffee stop, including tax and a service allowance; a breakfast sandwich changes the order total.

Seasonal flavours and filled doughnuts vary through the day.

Menu & venue information

Opening

Monday–Wednesday 04:30–18:00; Thursday–Friday 04:30–19:00; Saturday 05:00–19:00; Sunday 05:30–18:00.

Arrival

727 Manhattan Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11222

Look for the green shopfront, gold Peter Pan lettering and striped awning at 727 Manhattan Avenue.

Get directions

Ordering & tables

Walk in for the counter and takeaway service. Doughnut flavours and seasonal baking depend on the day’s selection; no table reservation is offered here.

Doughnut & breakfast menu

Accessibility

Ask the shop on 718 389 3676 about doorway and counter access. Doughnuts and breakfast foods can contain wheat, dairy, eggs and nuts; discuss cross-contact at the counter.

Location & nearby places

Explore around Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop

The map will load when you reach it.

Continue exploring / New York

Find another place for your itinerary, or explore all things to do in New York.

06 / Good to know

Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop: frequently asked questions

01Is it only a doughnut shop?

The menu also includes bagels, made-to-order breakfast sandwiches, pastries and hot and cold drinks.

02What is the difference between the main doughnut types?

Raised doughnuts use a lighter yeast dough; cake doughnuts have a denser crumb. Peter Pan lists both, plus filled and seasonal varieties.