Skip to content
View nextRolo’s

Penny

An upstairs East Village seafood counter for shellfish on ice, sesame brioche and carefully cooked fish.

Plan this experience
Explore the story
Cost≈ $128.88 per person
Time to allowAllow about 90 minutes.
PlaceEast Village, Manhattan

01 / The experience

Seafood along a white marble counter.

An upstairs East Village seafood counter for shellfish on ice, sesame brioche and carefully cooked fish.

$$$À la carte seafood. The editable food allowance is $90 per person before drinks, tax and tip; shellfish platters and larger fish dishes change the total.Seafood & raw bar

Penny’s long white marble counter is both the dining room and the edge of the kitchen. Sitting here puts shellfish preparation, bread coming from the oven and the movements of a small team within view. The narrow upstairs room has no conventional spread of dining tables: counter seating shapes the entire experience, from a few oysters to a full seafood dinner.

Chase Sinzer and chef Joshua Pinsky opened Penny above their restaurant Claud on East 10th Street. The two spaces have different characters. Penny’s pale marble, stainless steel and open preparation area make the seafood the focal point, with a long line of stools keeping guests close to the work. It is an intimate setting for two or a small party who enjoy the theatre of a working kitchen.

The raw bar’s ice box is a distinctive starting point, arranging shellfish in a compact tray rather than a towering display. Sesame-topped brioche supplies a warm counterpart, with butter and anchovies among its accompaniments. The food then moves beyond the raw bar: oyster preparations beneath pastry, stuffed squid and Dover sole have appeared on the menu. These dishes show the kitchen’s interest in cooking seafood as well as presenting it on ice. The current menu determines the available fish and preparations.

Wine is a substantial part of the restaurant’s identity, with the collection reaching well beyond a short list of seafood-friendly whites. Yet the counter also supports a smaller meal built around shellfish and bread. That flexibility, alongside nightly walk-in seating, gives Penny a different rhythm from a prepaid tasting restaurant. Its place in a New York food trip is a close encounter with seafood and the people preparing it, in a room whose limited space has become one of its defining strengths.

Penny, New York
Destination diningPennyNew York

04 / Before you go

Plan your visit

Allow about 90 minutes.

Food & drink

≈ $128.88 per person

Food allowance
$90.00
Soft drink allowance
$10.00

À la carte seafood. The editable food allowance is $90 per person before drinks, tax and tip; shellfish platters and larger fish dishes change the total.

Editable meal allowance, including a soft drink, sales tax and a 20% tip allowance. Replace it with the actual total; do not add another tip where service is included.

Drinks, supplements and the selected booking can change the total.

View current menu

When to visit

Every night, 17:00–22:30.

Arrival

Astor Place · 6

90 East 10th Street, New York, NY 10003

At 90 East 10th Street, use Penny’s upstairs entrance. Claud is the separate restaurant downstairs.

Get directions

Reservations

Resy reservations open 14 days ahead at 09:00 New York time. Walk-in seats are offered nightly, first come, first served. Use the official website for the current menu and booking link.

This is a seafood-focused counter. Arrange allergy requirements directly; do not assume vegetarian dishes or shellfish-free preparation are available.

Visit restaurant

Location & nearby places

Explore around Penny

The map will load when you reach it.

Continue exploring / New York

Find another place for your itinerary, or explore all things to do in New York.

06 / Good to know

Penny: frequently asked questions

01What should I order?

Start with shellfish from the raw bar and sesame brioche. The changing menu moves into hot seafood preparations, with the whole meal served at the counter.

02How do reservations work?

Resy reservations open 14 days ahead at 09:00 New York time. Walk-in seats are offered nightly, first come, first served. Use the official website for the current menu and booking link.

03What are the dietary and access considerations?

This is a seafood-focused counter. Arrange allergy requirements directly; do not assume vegetarian dishes or shellfish-free preparation are available. Penny is upstairs from Claud. Ask the restaurant about the actual step-free route and counter seating before booking.